Search This Blog

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

Commission to Put the Kabash on Free Speech


RESOLUTION REGARDING RULES OF PROCEDURE
FOR THE POCAHONTAS COUNTY COMMISSION

            BE IT RESOLVED, that the Pocahontas County Commission has determined that it requires some expansion of the Rules of Procedure governing meetings of the Pocahontas County Commission; and,
            WHEREAS, on the 1st of January, 2013, the then elected and serving members of the Pocahontas County Commission adopted a simplified voting procedure whereby the then Pocahontas County Commission adopted “… Roberts Rules of Order for small groups, to require a motion without a second and no final vote required for approval or passage, with each Commissioner having the authority to object, and noting that two objections (quorum) will cause a motion to fail.”; and
            WHEREAS, the Pocahontas County Commission has determined that such voting procedure should be amended to delete the reference to Roberts Rules of Order, and to expand the rules to deal with specific and necessary issues that arise during the course of a Commission meeting; and
            WHEREAS, generally, in a meeting of a deliberative assembly (such as the Pocahontas County Commission), business is conducted using a former procedure of motion, debate and vote.  However, in most issues before the Commission, action may be taken by unanimous consent.  The procedure of asking for unanimous consent is used to expedite business by eliminating the need for formal votes on routine questions in which the existence of a consensus is likely.  The principle behind it is that procedural safeguards designed to protect a minority can be waived when there is no minority to protect; and
            WHEREAS, the Pocahontas County Commission has operated under the doctrine of unanimous consent since January 1, 2013.  However, the simple adoption of unanimous consent is insufficient and additional rules of procedure are necessary.
            NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Pocahontas County Commission that the following rules shall apply at all meetings of the Pocahontas County Commission from and after the adoption of this resolution:
SPECIFIC RULES
1.       Purpose of Motion:                                           To adjourn.
            Form of Motion:                                               “I move to adjourn.”
            May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:              No.
            Need for Second:                                              Yes.
            Subject to Discussion:                                         No.
            May it be Amended:                                        No.
            Vote Necessary:                                               Yes.





2.       Purpose of Motion:                               To recess.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to recess for . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

3.       Purpose of Motion:                               To register a complaint or to ask a question.
Form of Motion:                                   “I have a complaint/question regarding . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  No.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   No.

4.       Purpose of Motion:                               To follow the agenda if business is interrupted.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to follow the agenda.”
May it Interrupt the Business on Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  No.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   No.

5.       Purpose of Motion:                               To close discussion.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to close discussion.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                      Yes.

6.       Purpose of Motion:                               To limit or extend discussion.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move that discussion be limited/extended to. . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

7.       Purpose of Motion:                               To postpone to a certain time.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to postpose the matter to . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.




8.       Purpose of Motion:                               Refer to a committee.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to refer the issue to . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

9.       Purpose of Motion:                               To amend.  For amendment both the persons                                                                              making the original motion and the second must consent                                                             to the proposed amendment prior to the vote.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to amend the motion by . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

10.   Purpose of Motion:                               To “kill” the motion.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move that the motion be postponed indefinitely.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

11.   Purpose of Motion:                               To change the agenda.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move that the agenda be changed as follows . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.                

12.   Purpose of Motion:                               To enforce the rules.
Form of Motion;                                   “I move to enforce the rules.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  No.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   No.

13.   Purpose of Motion:                               To override the chair.
Form of Motion:                                   “I appeal from the decision of the chair”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                    Yes. 


14.   Purpose of Motion:                               To suspend the rules.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to suspend the rules.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes. 

15.   Purpose of Motion:                               Objection.
Form of Motion:                                   “I object to the consideration of the question.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  No.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes. 

16.   Purpose of Motion:                               Question of law.
Form of Motion:                                   “I have a legal question for our counsel.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   No.

17.   Purpose of Motion:                               Request for information.
Form of Motion:                                   “Point of information.”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  No.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   No.

18.   Purpose of Motion:                               To table a motion.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to table . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for Second:                                  Yes. 
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

19.   Purpose of Motion:                               To rescind prior action.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to rescind . . .
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             Yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.




20.   Purpose of Motion:                               To reconsider.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to reconsider . . . “
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  No.
Need for Second:                                  Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

21.   Purpose of Motion:                               To read by title only.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to read by title only.”
May it interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for a Second:                               Yes.
Subject to Discussion:                           No.
May it be Amended:                             No.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

22.   Purpose of Motion:                               To Amend a Pending Motion.
Form of Motion:                                   “I move to amend the motion by . . .”
May it Interrupt Business on the Floor:  Yes.
Need for a Second:                               Yes, plus the person who seconded the original motion                                                                must agree to withdraw the second.
Subject to Discussion:                           Yes.
May it be Amended:                             Further Amended, yes.
Vote Necessary:                                   Yes.

            The foregoing listing of motions are for example.  All regular business shall be accompanied by simple motions such as: “I move to pay invoices,” and the like.  Motions that fail to obtain a second, fail for lack of a second.  Discussion of any issue should never precede the motion or the second and should commence only after the President of the Commission calls for discussion.  No member of the public should engage in this discussion as this is for the Commissioners to discuss amongst themselves in order to prepare to vote.                                              
GENERAL RULES

1.       A quorum shall consist of two (2) Commissioners in order to conduct business;
2.       In the event that only two (2) Commissioners are in attendance, a split vote on any issue causes the mater to fail; in the event of the absence of the President, the commissioner who has served  longer between the Commissioners in attendance, shall serve as temporary President;
3.       An agenda for all meetings of the Commission shall be prepared and posted in compliance with the Open Meetings Act and all applicable ethics rules regarding content and publication;
4.       All meetings shall be open to the public and conducted in compliance with these rules, the Open Meetings Act and all applicable ethics rules; all votes shall be cast in open sessions;
5.       Executive sessions are permitted for only those items/issues set forth in the Open Meeting Act and all applicable ethics rules and legal authority;
6.       Any member of the public wishing to address the Commission on any appropriate matter must sign on the “hear callers” sheet and state the issue upon which the person wishes to address prior to the start of the meeting; the agenda shall have a reserved time slot for “hear callers” and the President shall recognize each speaker; the President may recognize any speaker during “hear callers” or in the discretion of the President, the President may defer and allow such person to speak at a later time on a specific agenda item;
7.       The President may in the discretion of the President, limit both the number of speakers on any issue and the length of time speakers may address the Commission;
8.       Any and all comments made by the public must be addressed to the Commission and not to any other person; members of the audience shall not speak at any time unless recognized to speak by the President and shall not question nor engage persons addressing the Commission;
9.       Any person willfully disrupting or molesting the orderly and peaceful process of the County Commission may be charged under W.V. Code, § 61-6-19, and shall be removed from the meeting of the County Commission, and subject to fine and imprisonment.  However, any assembly in a peaceable, lawful and orderly manner for a redress of grievances does not violate this rule nor W.V. Code, § 61-6-19;
10.   Any motion, order or resolution passed or adopted by the Commission may be thereafter signed by the President of the Commission regardless of whether or not such motion, order or resolution specifically provides for such execution.  The President is authorized by the passage or adoption of any motion, order or resolution to execute any and all documents necessary to effect the purposes of such motion, order or resolution;
11.   Nominations for any position appointed by the Commission may be made by any citizen of Pocahontas County and does not require a separate nomination by any Commissioner.  Nominations and appointments shall be by acclamation unless one Commissioner shall object and, in such event, such appointment shall be by majority of both remaining Commissioners acknowledging in the affirmative. 
            Accordingly, the Pocahontas County Commission has determined that it does not and should not be bound by the intricacies and antiquities of Roberts Rules of Order.  However, the Commission desires
to have a more simple and understandable set of rules which the public can easily understand, and in order for the public to easily follow the procedures before the Commission and to expedite the business of the County.              THEREFORE, the Pocahontas County Commission does hereby adopt the foregoing


simplified Rules of Procedure, this the ______ day of _____________________, 2019, upon the affirmative vote of the now elected and serving members of the Pocahontas County Commission.



                                                                                    _______________________________________
                                                                                    DAVID MCLAUGHLIN, PRESIDENT



                                                                                    _______________________________________
                                                                                    JESSE A. GROSECLOSE, COMMISSIONER



                                                                                    _______________________________________
                                                                                    WALT HELMICK, COMMISSIONER


                                   




                                                                                                 
           
              

No comments:

Post a Comment

We are making comments available again! You are free to express your First Amendment Rights Here!

About Me

A local archivist who specializes in all things Pocahontas County